Best Tesla Model S Insurance Cost For 2023: [Compare + Buy]

Tesla Model S Insurance

Finding the best Tesla Model 3 Insurance cost can be tricky if you don’t know how to get car insurance for the first time. People make mistakes because they don’t compare car insurance quotes online or don’t know how to compare car insurance quotes. All this often results in paying higher premiums for auto insurance policies. Spending more money is not a wise option. We recommend shopping around, researching car insurance policies compared to other companies, and then buying or renewing.

Tesla cars are expensive, and you can find tesla car prices in our previous article, Tesla Model 3 insurance, where the MSPR starts at $40,000. All the tesla models have different insurance rates according to location, zip codes, trim levels, credit score history, age, and gender. Let Mount Shine’s comparison of Tesla Model S insurance costs help you save money on your next auto insurance policy and make the best financial decision. Get a car insurance quote for the Tesla Model S and buy/renew. Save money on insurance policy by contacting us.

Our study will guide you on car insurance rates, banks auto loans, crash test results, safety ratings, and how you can save money on car insurance. Following our study on how to get cheaper car insurance for Tesla Model S will help you get a lower insurance policy up to $203 per month. You can also compare auto insurance quotes side by side with other manufacturers. Check where Tesla cars rank with other vehicles like BMW, Audi, HondaHyundai, and other manufacturers.

How Much Does A Tesla Model S Insurance Costs In 2023?

The average insurance cost for Tesla Model S is $2,434 per year or around $203 per month, depending on the car’s features.

Here is the breakdown of Tesla Model S car insurance costs to see how much the individual coverages, comprehensive Coverage, liability coverage, and collision coverage:

  • Individual Coverage, comprehensive Coverage for Tesla Model S Insurance – $714 a year.
  • Liability/Medical for Tesla Model S Insurance – $588.
  • Collision coverage for Tesla Model S Insurance – $1,124.

Compare the average Tesla Model S insurance prices changes based on the age of the driver and coverage deductibles from the table below:

Driver AgeDeductibleAnnual CostMonthly Cost

When compared Tesla Model S liability-only insurance in the cheapest areas of Maine or Idaho costing $208 a year to Detriot, Michigan that can cost $44,108 a year for a full coverage insurance policy. The increase in price is because of the accidents and violations a teen driver can make. Whenever traffic rules are not obeyed, the insurance price is always higher no matter what of what age the driver is.

This is very important information to know as many people ask can an 18-year-old get their own car insurance? What happens if you get pulled over without insurance? Most newbies don’t know how to get car insurance for the first time? These quotes will help eliminate the guesswork and you can get cheap car insurance for Tesla Model S.

Also Read – Joint Auto Loan Explained!

How Much Does Used Tesla Model S Insurance Cost In 2023?

Tesla is expensive, that’s true, but used tesla car is not, and they can be a smart choice to buy and insure. It costs less to insure them, maintenance cost is also low, mileage is excellent, and ownership is easily transferable.

Used Tesla Model S Insurance Cost

The table below compares the average Tesla Model S insurance rates for the 2013 to 2022 model years. By comparing, you will understand the rates for Tesla Model S cars and clear any confusion about whether to go with a new Tesla or a used one.

Model Year and VehicleAnnual Rate6-month RateMonthly Rate
2022 Tesla Model S$2,434$1,217$203
2021 Tesla Model S$2,336$1,168$195
2020 Tesla Model S$2,286$1,143$191
2019 Tesla Model S$2,030$1,015$169
2018 Tesla Model S$2,088$1,044$174
2017 Tesla Model S$2,034$1,017$170
2016 Tesla Model S$1,982$991$165
2015 Tesla Model S$2,032$1,016$169
2014 Tesla Model S$1,938$969$162
2013 Tesla Model S$1,738$869$145

Compare Tesla Model S Insurance Cost vs. Midsize Luxury Cars (2023)

While doing our research, we found that the Tesla Model S ranks 34 out of 38 compared to midsize luxury cars. There can be a difference of $416 in the average category cost and full coverage annually. Below the table compares the Tesla Model S with other midsize luxury cars:

RankMake/ModelInsurance CostDifference
1Acura ILX$1,404-$1,030
2Lexus RC 300$1,690-$744
3Mercedes-Benz AMG CLA35$1,732-$702
4BMW i4$1,740-$694
5Cadillac CT5$1,744-$690
6Audi A3$1,762-$672
7Mercedes-Benz AMG CLA45$1,770-$664
8Mercedes-Benz CLA250$1,782-$652
9Lexus ES 250$1,784-$650
10Lexus IS 300$1,786-$648
11Lexus ES 350$1,794-$640
12Genesis G80$1,832-$602
13Audi S5$1,854-$580
14BMW 530i$1,890-$544
15Lexus ES 300h$1,896-$538
16Mercedes-Benz E350$1,908-$526
17BMW 530e$1,926-$508
18BMW 540i$1,930-$504
19Audi S4$1,938-$496
20BMW M440i$1,940-$494
21Mercedes-Benz E450$1,948-$486
22Audi A6$2,000-$434
23Jaguar XF$2,006-$428
24Lexus IS 500$2,028-$406
25BMW 430i$2,050-$384
26Mercedes-Benz CLS450$2,064-$370
27Audi RS 5$2,166-$268
28Mercedes-Benz AMG C43$2,186-$248
29Audi S6$2,198-$236
30Infiniti Q50$2,224-$210
31Mercedes-Benz AMG C63$2,254-$180
32BMW M550i$2,340-$94
33Audi A7$2,394-$40
34Tesla Model S$2,434--
35Lexus LC 500h$2,464$30
36Audi S7$2,590$156
37BMW M8$2,606$172
38BMW M5$2,636$202

Don’t Miss – 580 Credit Score: Is It Good Or Bad To Get A Car Loan?

Compare Model S Insurance Cost To Similar Models (2023)

Tesla Model S car insurance policies compare to other midsize luxury sedan manufacturers in the industry, and we get to know its real potential. We see different models and compare their features whenever we buy a car. What we forget to compare are the maintenance and insurance costs that can become a burden on our financial expenditure later on.

We at Mount Shine have compared average car insurance quotes between the Model S and a similar model’s average purchase price or MSRP.

For a 2022 Tesla Model S, the average MSRP ranges from $94,990 to $129,990, depending on the model, so we compared it with BMW M5, Lexus LC 500h, BMW M8, and Audi S7.

Compare 2022 Tesla Model S Insurance vs. BMW M5

The average MSRP for a Tesla Model S in 2022 is $5,190 higher than the BMW M5, at $112,490 against $107,300. Compared to the BMW M5, a Tesla Model S costs $202 less per year on average to insure.

Compare 2022 Tesla Model S Insurance vs. Lexus LC 500h

The Lexus LC 500h’s average MSRP is $101,873 ($99,050 to $105,900), which is $10,618 less than the Tesla Model S’s average MSRP. On average, Tesla Model S insurance costs $30 less per year than insuring a Lexus LC 500h.

Compare 2022 Tesla Model S Insurance vs. BMW M8

The 2022 BMW M8 costs $20,677 more than the Tesla Model S, with an average MSRP of $133,167 ($130,000 to $139,500). On average, insuring a Model S costs $172 less per year than insuring a BMW M8.

Compare 2022 Tesla Model S Insurance vs. Audi S7

The Audi S7 costs an average of $87,550 ($84,600 to $90,500), which is $24,940 less than the Tesla Model S’s average price. Insuring a 2022 Model S costs $154 less per year on average than insuring an Audi S7.

Recommended –

Best Mortgage Lenders For First Time Buyers

Best Credit Cards For Low-Interest Rates

What Is The Cheapest Tesla Model S Insurance Cost In 2023?

The cheapest Tesla Model S insurance cost is for the Model S AWD at $2,284; the most expensive is Plaid AWD at $2,584 per year. As the trim level increases, the cost to insure a car also increases.

Tesla Model S Insurance Trim Level

The table below compares the 2022 Tesla Model S car insurance policy according to the trim level.

Tesla Model S Trim LevelAnnual Policy6-month PolicyPer Month
Plaid AWD$2,584$1,292$215

Must Read – Best Car Insurance For Bad Credit In 2023

How To Apply Car Insurance For Tesla Model S in 2023?

Let Mount Shine help you, we have a wide network of the best insurance companies across 50 states of the United States that guide you to the best offers, payment options, auto insurance deals, etc. Check yourself for Tesla Model S insurance costs and then buy or renew.

Get free Tesla Model S Insurance quotes, buy/renew, and save money on car insurance by contacting us. Hurry EMI starts as low as $203 per month in 2022! Our service is free, fast, and simple, so get started today!

Compare Tesla Car Insurance For Other Tesla Models (2023)

Compare Tesla car insurance for all models and analyze the rates for Tesla cars. Get the in-depth details for each Tesla model ranging from Tesla Model 3, Model X, and Model Y along with the age of the driver, deductibles, crash test results, safety features, etc.

Tesla Model 3

Tesla Model X

Tesla Model Y


Is Tesla Model S insurance cheaper in 2023?

The average insurance cost for Tesla Model S is $2,434 per year or around $203 per month, depending on the trim level. Compare all the models of Tesla as the price may vary from state to state, and other factors are also involved. Tesla Model S insurance rates in California will be cheaper than in Michigan or New York.

Is Tesla insurance expensive for used cars in 2023?

Car insurance for Tesla Model S new model costs $2,434 and when compared to used models like 2021, 2017, 2014, it costs $2,320, $2,020, $1,920, respectively. So, the answer is NO, the insurance for used cars is not expensive.

What is the cost of Tesla insurance in New York?

The average cost of Tesla Insurance in new York is $1,780 for Tesla Model 3.

What is the cost of Tesla insurance in Illinois?

The average cost of Tesla Insurance in New York is $1,350 for Tesla Model 3.

How much does Tesla model 3 car insurance cost in California?

The average insurance cost for the Tesla Model S for full coverage in the state of California is $2,786, or around $232 per month.

Which is the best insurance for Tesla model S?

Compare auto insurance quotes online from different companies who work across all 50 states and get the best insurance for Tesla Model S. We have a wide range of networks that will help you get cheap insurance and save money on your car policy.

How much is Tesla Model S insurance rates a month?

Tesla Model S insurance rates are $203 a month depending on the trim level.

How much is the average insurance cost for Tesla model 3?

The average insurance cost for Tesla Model 3 is $1,602 per year or around $134 per month depending on the features of the car. It is cheaper to insure when compared to Tesla Model S.

Where is Tesla insurance available in the United States?

Palo Alto, California-based Tesla currently offers auto insurance in Arizona, California, Illinois, Ohio, and Texas.

What all documents do I need to renew my Tesla Model 3 car insurance?

Purchase a policy in as little as one minute to get started. Go to your Tesla Account and sign in. Add additional drivers or vehicles to your policy by entering information such as your driver’s license number, address, and date of birth. After making your purchase, you will receive a confirmation email, and your Tesla Insurance card will be accessible to download in your Tesla Account. You can also use the Tesla app to see your policy paperwork, make changes to your policy, and submit a new claim.

Different coverage amounts depend on each driver’s demands, and situation, and not all insurance policies are made equal.

From where can I purchase insurance for my Tesla Model S car?

Customers can purchase insurance for Tesla Model S or any other Tesla model from its official website. The company has also planned to sell insurance and its electric vehicles combined.

Best Tesla Model S Insurance Cost For 2023: [Compare + Buy]
Best Tesla Model S Insurance Cost For 2023: [Compare + Buy]
Ankit Dhadwal
Ankit Dhadwal

Ankit Dhadwal: Author @ Mount Shine

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Join Our Tribe!
Mount Shine
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Shopping cart